Peer Review Process

Jurnal Nawala Politika (JNP) employs a rigorous double-blind peer review process to ensure the highest standards of academic quality and impartiality in evaluating submissions. This system guarantees that all manuscripts receive fair, unbiased assessments from field experts.

Peer Review Process

The journal's review process consists of multiple stages to maintain scholarly excellence:

1. Initial Screening

  • Assessment of scope alignment
  • Check for basic quality standards
  • Verification of submission guidelines compliance
  • Evaluation of relevance to political science

2. Double-Blind Review

  • Complete anonymity (authors & reviewers)
  • Bias-free evaluation
  • Content-focused assessment
  • Multiple expert reviewers

3. Expert Evaluation

  • Review by political science specialists
  • Critical assessment of scholarly merit
  • Constructive feedback for improvement
  • Recommendation on publication

Reviewer Responsibilities

Our expert reviewers evaluate submissions based on four key criteria:

Research Novelty

  • Original contributions to the field
  • Innovative perspectives
  • Meaningful literature advancement
  • Avoidance of redundant findings

Methodological Validity

  • Robust research design
  • Appropriate data collection
  • Proper analysis techniques
  • Alignment with conclusions

Argument Clarity

  • Logical structure
  • Coherent narrative
  • Clear writing style
  • Effective communication

Field Contribution

  • Theoretical advancements
  • Empirical significance
  • Policy implications
  • Practical applications

Tips for Authors

To enhance your manuscript's success in the review process:

Content

  • Strong evidence-based arguments
  • Explicit original contribution
  • Clear theoretical framework

Methodology

  • Valid and reliable data
  • Transparent documentation
  • Appropriate analysis methods

Presentation

  • Concise academic writing
  • Minimal jargon
  • Clear organization

Commitment to Quality

The double-blind peer review process reflects Nawala Politika's dedication to:

  • Maintaining rigorous academic standards
  • Ensuring impartial evaluations
  • Publishing credible, impactful research